Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

CustomMade Jewelers Reviews

5.0 Rating 5,038 Reviews
99 %
of reviewers recommend CustomMade Jewelers
5.0
Based on 5,038 reviews
Shipping & Delivery
Delivery Methods
Postal Service, Courier
Average Delivery Time
Next Day
On-time Delivery
99%
Accurate And Undamaged Orders
100%
Customer Service
Communication Channels
Email, Live Chat
Queries Resolved In
2 - 3 Hours
Customer Service
5 out of 5
Read CustomMade Jewelers Reviews

About CustomMade Jewelers:

We don’t just sell engagement rings—we help you make one that’s only yours. Designed from scratch. Crafted by hand. Made to mean more.

Visit Website

Location:

90 Sherman St, CustomMade.com,
90 Sherman St, CustomMade.com
02140

CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 21st November 2026
Joshua Shelton
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 18th November 2026
Katherine Kolden
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 24th August 2026
Jaden Dosanjh
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 23rd August 2026
Anonymous
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 22nd August 2026
Caden Palmer
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 22nd August 2026
Anonymous
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 20th August 2026
Emily Livingston
1762
Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
“Every step from the design to shipment, you have someone in constant contact. So much help is available and no question goes unanswered. Pieces for every budget from sterling silver with quartz stones to top of the line. I had the my wife's engagement and wedding rings fully customized to exactly what we was looking for. The cost was only a few hundred dollars more than some run of the mill peice, but with it being completely custom, one of a kind, SO VERY WORTH IT!! Custom Made is my jewelry store for life I'll never go to another store.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Made the process easy and amazing . Felt like not only was I being listened to but also completely understood. The variety of options and flexibility on their part let me get the perfect ring for my dream woman.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I couldn't sing enough praises about Custom Made and my experience with the design team!!! Everyone was professional from start to finish and made me feel as though mine was the only project they were working on. I already proposed to Jenn and, in her words, she's obsessed with the design! Thank you so much for the constant support and communication throughout this entire project. I will most definitely be recommending Custom Made to everyone and will likely use it in the future to design some more incredible creations!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“CustomMade completed, without a doubt, the most stunning piece of jewelry I've ever seen. My wife fell in love with it the moment she saw it. The team behind the rings design worked closely with me for months until it was flawless. The pricing was beyond fair, and I will be using them for all future jewelry purchases. Tried to upload the stunning photo but it was too large ):”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“A wonderful experience for a special moment in one’s life, they’re very understanding and helped me achieve my goal!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“In the last few months I had a pair of custom made earrings made and a beautiful wooden trash can. I love both. Thank you all so much!”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 2nd March 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“The experience was wonderful. I loved building my own personlized signet rings from scratch. They were helpful and thoughtful. The staff was very patient with me even when i changed my mind a million times. 10/10 would recommend and i will def be using them in the future. :)”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Great communication and attention to detail, couldn't have asked for a better ring and quality”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Very helpful, quick to reply, great customer service, and great quality of products. everyone was very helpful and patient as I picked out the material and ring that worked best for what i wanted!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Truly wonderful. Great every step of the way. Beautiful work. I love how they communicated and never pressured me into anything i wasn’t looking for. Thank you!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I am a huge fan of Custom Made and very picky about jewelry - so this is perfect! The process is so easy and everyone is so patient. I got several versions of my ideas to choose from until i was 100% satisfied that my vision came to life. I really appreciate the accurate cost estimates and transparency too. Everyone does a really good job of keeping your vision within your budget, even if it means using different materials or widths. BUT they will not sacrifice the integrity of the project so that you still get a quality product. I LOVE CUSTOM MADE. ❤️”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 29th February 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Great experience, very communicative and easy process”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Great communication regarding changing the details a few times on this custom order, and the team working on it was more than accommodating and overly professional.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I loved my experience with CustomMade! Throughout the whole process I felt like I was taken good care of, and that I was provided with all the information I needed to make the right choices. Whenever I had questions or made a request to try something different, I always got the sense that they were doing their very best to help me. Big thanks to all the artists at CustomMade for helping me make something truly special for my fiancé!”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 28th February 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 28th February 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 28th February 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 28th February 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“A 5 ⭐️ company all the way from design to production to completion fast shipping, when I received my club ring it was even more impressive in person than I could ever of imagined, a big thanks to all the team at CustomMade!”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 28th February 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“My Custom made experience was amazing. They kept on touch through the whole process. My husband's pendent is perfect, he doesn't have it yet its an anniversary gift but i know he will love it too. Thank you for a great piece Michelle”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I am very please with the Cusotm Made perforamnce in my recent order of my University school ring.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“The staff was extremely patient and helpful throughout the whole design process and the final product is stunning. I look forward to working with CustomMade again on our next piece.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Here's my take on the CustomMade experience: - I was minutes away from pulling the trigger on buying a ring from a different company after spending a lonnnng time really thinking seriously about what to choose and collaborating with my partner. During the checkout process I paused and decided to do a little more digging with customer reviews, and I was shocked to see what I found. I'll spare the specifics, but you know it's bad when there's multiple complaints with the Better Business Bureau. They certainly had me fooled until seeing that. - Whelp, hard stop on that plan. Now what? Back to the drawing board I guess. In the last place I thought would be helpful, I was reading through Reddit comments with people being brutally honest about their experiences with said company, and others chiming in with their recommendations / positive experiences. The one place that was unanimously agreed upon with positive reviews was CustomMade. Alright, curiosity has been piqued. - I pulled the photos from the previous ring I was about to buy and started the process out of curiosity here, and what came next was absolutely wonderful. This has truly been a one of a kind experience that just exudes professionalism and genuine care / respect from start to finish. I can't imagine I made this super easy for ya'll with my multitude of delays and radio silence from time to time. Despite my hiccups, ya'll just kept with it, and I can not thank you enough. When the ring was out for delivery I thought it was just going to be the ring in a box and that's it, I had no idea it would be a full kit. I was cracking up at the "proposal survival kit" haha. All in all, this was a solid 11/10 experience that I can not recommend enough. I hope all of you get a raise. Who can I talk to to make that happen haha. I'll pull a reverse Karen of "let me speak to your manager, these people NEED recognition and a raise".”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“The design process was so easy and everyone who worked with me was amazing. They really helped bring my idea for a custom engagement ring and wedding band to life. Definitely recommending them to everyone I know.”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 27th February 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
CustomMade Jewelers is rated 5.0 based on 5,038 reviews