Login
Start Free Trial Are you a business? Click Here

CustomMade Jewelers Reviews

5.0 Rating 5,038 Reviews
99 %
of reviewers recommend CustomMade Jewelers
5.0
Based on 5,038 reviews
Shipping & Delivery
Delivery Methods
Postal Service, Courier
Average Delivery Time
Next Day
On-time Delivery
99%
Accurate And Undamaged Orders
100%
Customer Service
Communication Channels
Email, Live Chat
Queries Resolved In
2 - 3 Hours
Customer Service
5 out of 5
Read CustomMade Jewelers Reviews

About CustomMade Jewelers:

We don’t just sell engagement rings—we help you make one that’s only yours. Designed from scratch. Crafted by hand. Made to mean more.

Visit Website

Location:

90 Sherman St, CustomMade.com,
90 Sherman St, CustomMade.com
02140

CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 21st November 2026
Joshua Shelton
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 18th November 2026
Katherine Kolden
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 24th August 2026
Jaden Dosanjh
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 23rd August 2026
Anonymous
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 22nd August 2026
Caden Palmer
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 22nd August 2026
Anonymous
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 20th August 2026
Emily Livingston
1762
Anonymous
Anonymous  // 01/01/2019
“The whole team went above and beyond to work with me on a customized pinky ring. Each lead from the jewelry consultant, design lead and production lead kept me informed on each part of the process and estimated time each would take. Even though there was a slight issue in the production process, I was provided the update immediately and had a new estimated date of completion right away. Quality work, effective communication, and top notch customer service! Highly recommend!”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 10th July 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Great service. Great Product”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Communication was very smooth. I was given many different options as well as visual representation of what to expect based on my choices. I was able to make choices based on my budget which was really nice. The entire process was very fast. They told me some times it could take months to work out a good design, but they worked so fast that my order got here BEFORE the date I really wanted it by! All team members were very clear and made sure to confirm everything before having me pay. I will definitely recommend custom made to anyone I meet looking for something they can make.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I'm sorry to say that I can no longer in good faith recommend anyone purchase jewelry via CustomMade - something has drastically changed, ?new personnel, without apparently as much training or passion or interest in the job at hand or desire to provide exemplary or even just okay customer service. I'd previously purchased 2 rings and had an absolutely fantastic experience, the rings were unique and there was a lot of care taken by and interest from folks like Czarina and Rosebud. More recently, with my 3rd ring, I've run into problems. In the past, missives to and from staff were extremely timely and re-sizing plans made with ease with appropriate UPS mailing labels provided without any issue. Please find below my last email to CustomMade staff - I received a reply stating that it would be escalated to someone and I would hear back by Tuesday (i.e.., today - I have received no response and don't feel certain that I will, which is very disappointing/baffled based on the stellar past experiences I had). "So I just tried again at another UPS store- was told same thing:/ they said the label I have doesn’t cover any packaging in which the ring would be shipped in. I’m afraid I’ve wasted a lot of time now printing and reprinting the mailing label I received and visiting different UPS stores. Am I not able to have the ring re-sized for free like with the other rings I purchased from CustomMade? Very disappointing if so! Was definitely a big reason why I’ve continued to be a customer. - Please feel free to forward this email chain to managing personnel- I just can’t believe how much more difficult and cumbersome the resizing process has been this 3rd time around (again had no difficulty whatsoever the other times), again super disappointing and an utter timewaster. I live in the city and have sat through traffic to try UPS stores in both Chicago and surrounding suburbs. Not sure what else I can do."”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“The whole team was great and made my thoughts turn into reality. Great and reliable company, use them and thank me later :)”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“CustomMade was wonderful to work with. From listening to all of the input I had, to making sure that me and my girlfriend would be super happy with the final product, they made the whole process really easy and I was able to get exactly what I was looking for. They were super kind and made a wonderful product that I am so happy about!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“The team was extremely helpful. I was skeptical about using a completely online service for my ring. However, they checked in several times through every step of the process. This made me feel much more comfortable.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“CustomMade went above and beyond to ensure my satisfaction and I'm so glad I chose them for my project!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“This was my first time purchasing a ring like this-I had no idea what I was really even looking for and the team from Custom Made made the process very simple and easy and helped me along the way providing many different options. Great company-very happy with the end result!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Awesome! Everyone responded in a timely manner and there was a lot of professionalism and patience, listening to every detail you have to give. From the ring design of my girlfriend to the real ring, omg spectacular, I definitely recommend CustomMade. Happy with the end product of the ring. I cannot wait to propose!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“The design process was really smooth. All representatives were very attentive and communication with them was very efficient. The team was very willing to give life to the ring idea that I had in mind. Overall, they guided me on every step of the way and delivered on every change and details that I requested. They mean it when they say they will keep working on it until you are 100% happy with the design. In all, I loved the personalized process they offered and I am extremely happy with my piece. The final ring in person was a perfect match to the design renderings we agreed. Outstanding service.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“My inability to find what I had in mind led me to CM in the first place. And while it may be true that it easier to buy out of the Jeweler's display case, nothing compares to the distinction of having a completely unique, "made-for-you" piece. As I was very specific regarding what I wanted, I was impressed with the extraordinary patience and attention to design detail as well as the subsequent follow up from production. In the end, I opened the package from CM to find that they had captured my vision exactly.”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 7th July 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Working with the CustomMade staff was amazing! I wanted to create the perfect ring to ask the woman of my dreams to marry me but i had no idea what that ring looked like. They made it super easy to communicate with them and to tweak the design until i was happy with it, no matter how many changes it took! They were professional, personable, punctual and made me feel like they cared if i liked the ring! The process was easy to understand and all i had to do was design it online and wait for it to be shipped! For a custom project the pricing is way better than i have been quoted anywhere else! I will 100% be using CustomMade for our wedding bands in the future!”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I am very pleased with my ring. I had already had my crest design so it made the begining process very easy. The speed at which the company designed the ring and had it to finished product was very quick. It is a high quality ring with a very nice look to the design and overall product. The face is a little smaller that what I was hoping for but I guess the ring could only be so big. The price of the ring was a little expensive but if you compare it to a high quality wedding ring set it is cheap in comparison. Overall very happy with my experience and my final ring. Thank you for the great support and high quality ring.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Working with Custom Made was excellent throughout the entire process. I was a little hesitant to entrust my ring purchase entirely online but the Custom Made team worked with me through every step of the process to ensure that I understood each step and was happy with the results. From the initial conceptual renderings through the final design, I was impressed with the team’s thoroughness and attention to detail. In the end, the ring was perfect - exactly what I was hoping for and most importantly, my new fiancé’ loved it! Thank you to the whole Custom Made team for helping make this possible!”
CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 6th July 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 6th July 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 6th July 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 6th July 2024 CustomMade Jewelers 5 star review on 6th July 2024
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“My previous and current design projects came out just as I imagined, maybe even better than my expectations. ❤️ Thank you for breathing life into my precious design with your amazing craftsmanship. ~ Navi.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“From the first intercation of narrowing down what i was looking for Sonny, Will Vincent and Pauline were nothing but helpful, insightful and quick with their responses. It was a pleasure going through the entire process with them. Cannot recommend enough if looking for an engagement ring”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Very good customer service easy to work with an quality craftsmanship, my now soon to be wife loves her ring”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“I had a great experience getting a truly unique and beautiful ring created. The entire team worked to make the whole process easy. I highly recommend CustomMade for anyone looking to have a ring created.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
“Overall I was verry happy with the experience. The people helped and guided me through the process. Were inquisative where needed. And were more than willing to make adjustments to the design. I had lots of choices and got to make informed descisions all the way through, and I got regular updates where things were, and where we we were going. The cost production was on the higher end IMO. And some little detailed work that needed to be done by hand was not possible. Overall, verry happy with the result/experience/delivery time.”
Helpful Report
Posted 2 years ago
CustomMade Jewelers is rated 5.0 based on 5,038 reviews